8 minute watch | November.16.2026
The US International Trade Commission (ITC) has five new Commissioners – and early signals point to closer scrutiny of the domestic industry requirement, especially for patent holders without US manufacturing.
Orrick’s Josh Pond, Jordan Coyle and Tom Chen break down what makes the ITC unique, how best to work with the Office of Unfair Import Investigations, and what they heard directly from the Commissioners at the ITC Trial Lawyers Association annual meeting.
Note: This video requires functional cookies to load.
Recorded November 4, 2026.
JOSH POND: The U.S. International Trade Commission is undergoing tidal change in the form of new Commissioners. In particular, there's five brand-new Commissioners joining just one who is remaining with the Commission. But first, some quick introductions. I am Josh Pond. I'm a partner here in our Washington, D.C. office. Very happy to be joined by Jordan Coyle, another partner in the D.C. office, rejoining Orrick. And Tom Chen, who joined Orrick a couple of years back directly from the USITC. Also on our bench for ITC is Bas de Blank, out of our Silicon Valley office.
Jordan, maybe you could just share what you see as sort of the essence of this unique institution.
JORDAN COYLE: Yeah, I thought I'd mention maybe three things that I think make the ITC unique. The first is, of course, the speed. And everybody talks about how the Commission tries to resolve these cases in 16 months. But I think maybe the more probative statistic is time to trial, where in the ITC, we're almost guaranteed to get to trial in less than a year from the time the complaint is filed. And that's less than half the time it takes to get to trial in the Eastern District of Texas, and even less time than it takes to get to trial in other patent-heavy venues like Delaware or the Northern District of California.
So what that means for a complainant is you have this opportunity to get this huge head start and get a resolution really quick. But I always advise complainants, don't let that momentum lag. Once you get the complaint filed, you want to keep up the pressure on respondents, so you always have that time advantage. And on the respondent side, as soon as you see notice of that complaint hit your company, you want to start engaging counsel and start preparing for that investigation. So you want to hire counsel that can immediately put into action maybe four or five different workstreams to try to close that gap.
A second distinguishing aspect of the ITC is the remedy that the ITC offers, which is to exclude infringing products from the United States. The Commission actually has the power to issue what's called a general exclusion order, which blocks all infringing products from coming into the United States, even if those products are not imported or manufactured or designed by a named respondent. We represented BIC in obtaining a general exclusion order that protects their iconic pocket lighter. So any pocket lighter that's imported in the U.S. that looks like this BIC pocket lighter is now blocked from coming in. And Josh, I think you have similar experience with this.
JOSH: Yeah. We achieved a similar general exclusion order for Hydro Flask. These are the beautiful, fancy water bottles. And they were coming in from a lot of different sources, so we achieved a general exclusion order against all look-alike Hydro Flask water bottles.
JORDAN: And we have experienced general exclusion orders on the other side as well. For example, we represented one of the world's largest display makers when a major competitor of theirs filed a complaint with the ITC, sought a general exclusion order, but did not name our client despite its size. We advised the client to intervene to protect itself, and it did, and we achieved a successful outcome for that client.
And the third thing I want to mention that makes the ITC so unique is the institutional expertise that is present in the ITC. And I think it starts with the administrative law judges who focus on these claims, in comparison to more generalist district court judges. But more importantly for today, a lot of institutional expertise in the Office of Unfair Import Investigations. And who better to talk about that than Tom?
TOM CHEN: Thank you, Jordan. I was very lucky to have a chance to work in that office for almost five years. There's about 20 attorneys in the group, and they're all highly experienced, extremely hardworking attorneys who bring a lot of institutional knowledge to their investigations.
JORDAN: And what role do they usually play in those investigations?
TOM: They play two principal roles in an ITC investigation. Early on at the institution stage, they'll review a complaint and assess its sufficiency, and provide a recommendation to the Commissioners about whether to institute an investigation. Once an investigation is instituted, they take on a different role as an independent third party representing the public interest. And because they are an independent third party that takes an objective view of the evidence, the ALJs are often very interested in their positions and views in the case.
JOSH: And I'll just give a visual. I mean, everybody knows a typical courtroom with plaintiff's table, defendant's table. At the ITC, there's complainant, respondent and staff.
TOM: Exactly.
JORDAN: And so given that substantive role the staff plays, how should parties and their counsel interact with staff?
TOM: It's important to develop a positive working relationship and keep an open mind to communication early on in the investigation. I think one thing that surprises some parties is that you can have ex-parte communications with the staff, and it's confidential. It's not going to be discoverable. And so that's kind of your opportunity to work with the staff to develop your case. On the substantive merits, they sometimes bring a fresh perspective and spot issues or arguments that the private parties may not have, you know, uncovered on their own. So it can only benefit you to kind of work effectively with the staff and develop a positive relationship with them.
JOSH: So that does bring us to the new Commissioners. Just like any of the executive agencies here in Washington, D.C., the Commissioners at the U.S. International Trade Commission serve at the pleasure of the president. With the ITC, though, uniquely, the president is required to maintain three Democrats and three Republicans as Commissioners, on the theory that trade should be nonpartisan.
Over the summer, we got five new Commissioners, three Republicans, two Democrats, joining the one Democrat that stayed on. All five represent one or more of three different important backgrounds. They're either trade experienced, patent experienced, and/or congressionally experienced. We also just got the opportunity to hear four of these Commissioners speak just yesterday at the annual International Trade Commission Trial Lawyers Association meeting. Jordan, what were your takeaways?
JORDAN: Yeah, certainly a renewed focus on domestic industry. The ITC was set up as a trade agency to protect U.S. industries from unfair foreign competition. So that means that a threshold requirement for any complainant in a 337 investigation is to show that a domestic industry exists that is worthy of protection. And there are different ways of showing that that domestic industry exists. The first one that comes to mind may be that products are manufactured in the U.S. that practice the asserted intellectual property. That is certainly a basis for domestic industry that the Commissioners yesterday threw their weight behind. That's going to be a very important factor going forward. But it's not the only way to show that a domestic industry exists. You can rely on investments of a licensee. You can rely on your own investments in research and development and engineering and product development and things like that.
We've seen some very substantial opinions from the Federal Circuit in the last couple of years. Now we have Apple-Masimo up at the Supreme Court. But it's amazing after all these years that the domestic industry inquiry is still such an open question, and it really gives us a fun place to play with the law and the facts. But the Commission has directed parties to think more concretely about this. Right, Tom?
TOM: Yeah, that's one thing we're seeing in the recent institution notices, is an explicit request that the parties devote special care to developing a full record on this issue.
JORDAN: Yeah. And the other thing we heard from the Commissioners yesterday was data, data, data. They all want more data on domestic industry, whether that's about domestic investments or contextualizing those investments. So a lot more for us to work on with our clients.
JOSH: Yeah, yeah. One of the quotes from yesterday that really stuck with me is the new chair, Brett Doyle, put it out there in his remarks that the Commission has been far too eager to find domestic industry in the past. So, you know, I think this boils down to: if you are a U.S. patent holder with manufacturing in the United States, you're going to be pretty good on DI, as long as you get your burden of proof borne. But if you don't have U.S. manufacturing, you've got to be even more thoughtful. It's quite doable, and we're very experienced with carrying that burden or making the other side carry that burden.
Well, we here at Orrick would be happy to talk at any time about both offensive and/or defensive approaches at the USITC. Thanks, Jordan. Thanks, Tom.
JORDAN AND TOM: Thanks, Josh. Thank you.