Often the individuals named in a securities class actions
are represented by the same lawyers representing the company.
While sometimes that can be in the best interest of all parties,
that strategy may create friction and inherent conflicts.
In order to fully understand the situation at hand, individuals
must consider whether or not the company's interests
are aligned with their own, if a criminal investigation is
likely or ongoing, or if there is an SEC proceeding. When
the question of separate counsel is not clear, a behind-the-scenes
representation of the individual — called "shadow counsel" — may be the best alternative.
We advise clients at the onset that it is critical to confront
these potential hazards at the beginning of any pending lawsuit
and decide if additional counsel is necessary. Our lawyers
are experienced in evaluating the critical components that
make up these decisions. We work with both the individual
and the company by reviewing:
If there is risk of an SEC or a criminal proceeding
If there is the likelihood of a fine or D&O bar
If the risk of separate contribution to the class action
settlement
We are also experienced in ensuring that the D&O insurance
carrier and the company will indemnify the individual, assessing
the appearance of individuals "lawyering up."
We know which forums are most important, which must be dealt
with first, and-perhaps most importantly - how a move in one
arena affects the outcome in the others.
Challenges include:
Evaluating whether separate counsel is appropriate
Evaluating the risk of an SEC proceeding
Evaluating the criminal risk
Evaluating the likelihood of a fine or D&O bar
Evaluating the risk of separate contribution to the class
action settlement
Ensuring that the D&O insurance carrier and the company
will indemnify the individual
Assessing the appearance of individuals "lawyering
up"
Our perspective has been earned defending premier public
companies and financial institutions in hundreds of securities
class actions and enables us to effectively represent: